Dear Shaded Viewers,
Going to see the ballet, the opera, or any traditional stage performance has always felt somewhat inaccessible. Maybe it’s the formality, the conventions surrounding them, maybe it feels that they belong to another generation. Until Doja Cat lashed out at Timothée Chalamet over his comments that “no one cares” about ballet and opera anymore, I don’t think I had paid much mind to the resurgence of traditional performing arts amongst my own generation. But, like much else in the arts, there is a sense of resistance and persistence as traditional forms find ways to adapt to contemporary tastes and growing digital spaces.
Dans(e) la lumière, to my pleasant surprise, is one such example. Supporting and showcasing young artists at the beginning of their careers, this annual event hosted at the Fondation Groupe EDF in Paris platforms a range of choreographic disciplines, including urban dance. In collaboration with IADU, a French incubator dedicated to hip-hop and urban dance, Dans(e) la lumière brings together performers whose practices explore a theme of relationships with others, the collective, oneself and one’s territory. Meaning ‘In the light’, Dans(e) la lumière reminds the audience of what light does: bringing visibility. Through defining the dancers’ contours, movement and rhythm, light becomes a performer in itself, bringing the drama and atmosphere of the stage to life. More crucially at this time, it illuminates the importance of creating and being together. With its exhibitions free and open to public, Dans(e) la lumière consciously breaks down the barriers of accessibility, in a circle that often feels the opposite.
As soon as I walked into the space, I was met with darkness, punctuated by strong red lights coming from various directions. Surrounding a stage that was the main source of light, I encountered three bodies sprawled across the floor. Limp limbs draped over a ballet barre or a barbell, they were all dressed in identical red sports jerseys and black jeans. The same two-dimensional face was printed onto each of them. Triplet figures, lying deflated on the floor.
We crowded around the edges of the room. Unsure of what we were waiting for, I stepped closer to the body sprawled lifelessly in front of the stage, my foot right next to its motionless face as I tried to get a good angle of the doll with my camera. I thought to myself, hmm, this one seems to look more realistic than the other ones. I stepped around to get a better look at its legs. They were slumped over a box, one on either side, seemingly disjointed, whilst the torso, arms and face sagged against the ground.
All of a sudden, the face turned, followed by the legs. Like a machine turning on, the rag doll suddenly came alive. A chill ran down my back. As if oiling its cogs and testing out its own body, a spirit overtook the body – a ghost in the machine. Responding to the music and light, which shifted from red to blue, the reanimated body moved in somewhat awkward yet strangely beautiful gestures, travelling from the floor onto the stage, each time finding a different point of contact with the ground. I felt as though I was watching Frankenstein’s monster learning how to use its body for the first time – perhaps this was a modern Frankenstein? As my head hurried to catch up with what my eyes were seeing, I realised that this third doll had been a human being, hidden in plain sight, all along.
Performed by Núria Guiu Sagarra, her performance narrates a hypothetical: what would happen if an avatar were to return to our physical world? Our physical bodies enter the digital world constantly, in the form of avatars, video game characters and social media profiles. But what would the reverse look like?
These avatar bodies have no actual weight or skeleton. In fact, they have to be taught how to move through their digital world like how we move through our physical world. If you’ve ever tried bringing a 3D character from Blender into Unreal Engine, you’d know the pain of rigging a skeleton and giving it convincing enough motion.
Dance is dependent on weight and fatigue – these are fundamental elements of a performance by the human body. A digital body, however, experiences neither. How then can you translate these human imperfections and limitations into a digital avatar? This is what Keep Dancing tries to investigate.
How then can you use a human body, which has both weight and fatigue, to act as though it were a digital avatar that had neither weight nor fatigue? The irony is that the most convincing digital body I encountered was not digital at all; it was Núria pretending to be one.
The question the artists kept returning to was: can you write a dance piece using avatar bodies?
Upstairs, they tried to tackle this question with a video featuring Núria’s digital avatar, multiplied across the screen and in different outfits. They moved in unison, running as though on treadmills, performing ballet steps and leaps in the air, before falling into formation like in a music video. Yes, they moved in perfect synchronisation. But where is the thrill for an audience in witnessing the possibility of multiple bodies moving as one? Where is the thrill of the possibility of seeing something slightly different in each? Where is the thrill of a live performance?
I’m not sure how dance and other performative arts, which live and thrive on the stage, can translate into a digital world. But judging by the audience’s response to Núria’s performance, I would say people still crave the physical closeness between audience and performer, perhaps now more than ever.
Towards the end of Núria’s performance, she stretched out her hand to a woman in the audience. The woman leaned back, chuckling awkwardly, and glanced around. The avatar stood there, unmoving, hand outstretched. Seconds passed. We all wondered: who is going to give in first? Eventually, the woman shook the avatar’s hand.
Later,
Estelle









