photographer credits – McQueen Reuters – Vanity Fair Annie Leibowitz – The Boys Steve Granitz – Troye Sivan Kai Gillespie
Dear Shaded Viewers,
Fashion needs to get real; clothes are what we need, not fantasy, but then where is the the gorgeous fantasy and the dressing up, what about glamour and aspirational fashion and where do we find escapist storytelling and romance?
I am writing this whilst there are marches, fighting, and disasters across the world, and the clothes we wear cannot exist in a world that ignores reality.
I also noted that the industry is still unsettled; with Seán McGirr leaving McQueen and will possibly be replaced by Virginia Burlina, and Anthony Vaccarello being “replaced” by Chemena Kamali at Saint Laurent, rumours of Pierpaolo Piccioli leaving Balenciaga after a year to be replaced by Martine Rose, and other “rumours” and gossip none of which are helpful to the business. This seemingly endless reshuffling of the designer at a house or brand has simply got to stop, it’s no longer interesting, it is silly. The executives and boards making these decisions are not thinking it through. “Quiet” is still key to fashion success, simply by letting a designer get on with the job.
All of these factors only added to my thoughts on where fashion has been, where it is, and it’s uncertain future. I start by asking the simple question, who needs “fashion” in today? What is its purpose in a world of conflict and instability, where the cost of living, daily life, and the future for young people are foremost in people’s thoughts? Across the world leaders and politicians, with little connection to the real world, decide our futures.
Then I looked at how fashion must also inspire, create, change, as well as add glamour and romance to our lives. The conflict and discussion, as well as analysis and understanding, of the balance between the past approach to storytelling. A time of incredible shows and presentations alongside brilliant and imaginative fashion shoots, and the present which is based around money, product and clothes for real life and day to day living.
So, this is the context of my thoughts. It’s about change, and change is weird, because sometimes it’s gradual and it truly does creep up upon you, other times it is clear and quick, but the most frustrating is when you know there’s change but can’t quite put your finger on it.
I have been wondering about diverse elements spinning around in my brain. It was the mismatch of the continuing importance of quiet luxury, despite many people’s boredom with this trend it continues. Yet at the same time my, and many other people’s, interest in narrative. I kept thinking about narrative and splendid big catwalk shows, and opulent many page fashion stories with glorious styling and exotic locations, yet at the same time thinking about real clothes, real lives, and the world in which we are living now. The two are seemingly at odds
So, I am going to explain how I think the two work together and the change they spell in fashion, and also what makes Diana Vreeland the starting point of my thoughts, leading me to the rather extraordinary Troye Sivan.
Mrs Vreeland was an editor who had a vision. She wished to show what clothes could do, what fashion might inspire in people, how what a model wore could become dreams or stories. Through her own dedication to beauty and the journey she had made on herself throughout her life, Mrs Vreeland wanted to show that it is possible to use style as part of life, to contribute to confidence, allure and even power. The pages she created or oversaw wove spells, from the breezy outdoor American clothes of the time, through to the florals of flower power, and hippies across to severe couture shot in black and white. She looked across the globe from snowy landscapes in Japan to the souks of Morocco, to the heat of India or the ruins of temples. The interesting thing is that often when you examine the stories the actual clothes themselves are not that extraordinary, but by alchemy via Diana Vreeland and the team they layered necklaces, the model struck poses against extraordinary locations and the photographers shot the moment. Babs Simpson and Polly Mellon understood exactly how to achieve the story, and although all three women, and others in the team, had their own ideas, styles, and visions, they saw clothes as a tool to tell a story. When printed and spread across the pages of Vogue we gazed in wonderment. Looking back, it was a huge shift for fashion to both travel and to attempt such narratives, but it was something Mrs Vreeland had started with Louise Dahl Wolfe at Harpers Bazaar. During her Vogue years she reached her peak. Then, as fashion shifted, she was out of step and the whole paraphernalia suddenly looked off kilter to the times. In some ways it was the right moment for Mrs Vreeland to pick up a fresh challenge and in a different arena.
Her next venture was to take on the costume archive, and exhibitions at the Metropolitan Museum of Art; she took it by the scruff of the neck and transformed fashion and costume exhibitions forever. The vision she bought to all her work meant spraying Ralph Lauren Polo fragrance through the salons of Man and the Horse, of producing an exhibition purely on then living designer Yves Saint Laurent and instructing the wig makers for the Eighteenth Century Woman to make them bigger and bigger.
In her footsteps have come Harold Koda and Richard Martin, and today, Andrew Bolton. The work they do would not be possible without the passion, drive, energy, and vision of Diana Vreeland to see beyond what others see, to enchant. Yet also to make us think about why the story is being told, what it means in terms of the world around us. It’s not simply storytelling just for its own sake or in isolation as a vanity project. It is deeply of the time, the moment, the day. It is a reflection of the world in which we live and get dressed in every day.
This led me on to another fashion genius. The most recent decade of extraordinary work by Grace Coddington is now being summed up in a third volume of images. She is also talking about the work, and how it’s changed. It is essential viewing and listening as Grace explains what has changed and shifted in her story telling, her selection of clothes and models, and what signature elements she continues to bring to her work. Grace still works because she saw the change and left behind fantasy stories, extravagant clothing and unavailable to order only couture.
This points us to the truth which is that fashion must reflect the world it’s worn in, and both these fashion geniuses understood this, the story has to relate to the reality both of life and what people are buying and wearing to live their lives in. Yet is can be made exciting and wonderful. Today the problems of life from climate to politics, from war to natural disasters, means it is serious times, and money, even for the rich, is to be spent wisely and may not offer the only answer to being safe, well, and happy.
We look back with nostalgia at Alexander McQueen & John Galliano, their extravagant shows, the insane ideas both for their own collections, and at Givenchy and Dior, respectively. Those who were there and those who have entered the fashion world since. I would also note there was also one other designer whose narrative thrust as thematic inspirations were so wonderful; Jean Paul Gaultier. From his very first collection real clothes, a modern wardrobe and great pieces were always at the heart of his work. “Le Concierge est dans l’escalier” being the perfect example of a brilliant show but one that also contained great tailoring, superb dresses, the best sweaters, etc all under a strong narrative. Gaultier also realised what he truly needed was to launch haute couture and offer extraordinary narratives, because his pret a porter was all about real clothes, and he needed a showcase for his extravaganza and fantasy ideas as well. I would also note that Thierry Mugler and Claude Montana were great at catwalk extravaganzas but also filled rails with real clothes and sold product during their peak years. Of course, during the early days of Dries van Noten offered stories and extravagant events showcasing the seasons collection, which were both right for establishing the house and the brand. They were also presented during a different time. Later this was no longer such an over arching requirement, since Dries had established his signature which gradually developed each season as a continuous arc rather than chopping and changing, but at the heart of the house are always beautiful pieces to buy wear and cherish.
Yet on balance fantasy fashion and extraordinarily strong seasonal narrative underpinning the collections have never been the whole story. The Italians and Americans have always focussed on reality, on making and selling the product. Giorgio Armani, Gianni Versace, Gianfranco Ferre, Gucci, Prada, Salvatore Ferragamo or Bottega Veneta. Bill Blass, Michael Kors or Ralph Lauren are just a few names of houses whose main raison d’être is business and product underneath the surface fashion glamour.
Today the huge lavish stories shot for Vanity Fair with actors, or the special made to order cover fantasies for Christmas from Diana Vreeland, featuring Grace Kelly or Sophia Loren would be inappropriate. Grace Coddington would no longer focus on Alice in Wonderland but a more realistic, even urban story. Once upon a time French Vogue asked guest editors such as Federico Fellini, or Marlene Dietrich to edit issues, would that still work I wonder.
Today there are other and diverse ways to use fashion and it’s not about story telling in the way it once was. Today, from Celine Dion wearing designers latest both onstage and on the streets immediately, to Zendaya at movie premiers literally taking the catwalk piece to wear, it is quick, fast, speedy. The clothes skip from runway to stars across all the arts at tope speed, plus the special pieces, see Jonathan Anderson for Dior, are not even from the catwalk but one off special couture pieces.
For me, the first memory of one major shift, or change I now believe was a pop video of Prince, where I realised that, uncredited, the girls behind him were wearing Dolce e Gabanna. Since then, we have had Bjork to Adele in clothes hot of the runway or made to order for the world of music. What Bob Mackie once designed especially for television stars is now straight off the catwalk. If we want to see the best directions in menswear right now, where better to look than the ever revolving wardrobe of Harry Styles every one of the thirty nights at Madison Square Garden “Together Together” tour. We don’t need a shoot in a glossy we have the real thing, indeed for menswear awards and premieres now offer some of the most extravaPersonally, my favourite recent moment I adore, is how Troye Sivan wore Erdem days after the show. Also, his “Party” video exemplifies how the perfect place for this kind of narrative is a pop promo movie. Merging Medieval chain mail, Tudor doublet and hose and Marc Forne has plundered archival and unreleased pieces, including items from Ludovic de Saint Sernin, Vivienne Westwood pirate boots, and an Alexander McQueen embroidered coat. Why scroll through a fashion spread when this narrative is alive?
In our desire for a dramatic narrative, we gaze at the splendid shows of Matières Fécales which have had a huge effect on many people. The truth however is that they have a great vision, but the clothes are not either modern or challenging in many ways. The fifties tailored suits, the New Look Portrait dresses, the Jacques Fath siren dresses, all look backwards for inspiration. In a sense they are indeed real clothes, it’s the spectacle, casting and show that is making a cultural statement. Again, it’s interesting to repeat that Grace Coddington says she now wants to shoot real clothes in her stories, and looks back at her fantasies as a past era.
Real clothes in artificial scenarios is modern, performers whisking the catwalk pieces away to wear immediately is how fashion works today. The nostalgia for Galliano at Dior and Margiela meant that the Zara pieces were purchased in a false hope that they could or would recapture a fashion style that is now history. I checked and much is still available or more was made and delivered than we thought. The unboxing videos verge on the sad, often with the purchasers trying the pieces on in “Galliano” poses, underlining that the most desirable of these pieces are dressing up box, not real. A friend told me she’d not bought the best most elaborate pieces because she couldn’t think of when or where she would wear them.
For the foreseeable future as America and Russia talk, Britain regrets Brexit, wars rage on, prices rise and new pandemics arise, and the streets fill with angry people, fashion isn’t the place for fantasy at any level. The white rabbit may be late but he must be in the right place, wearing the right clothes and his white gloves must be eternally clean. Tell us a story by all means, but like Mrs Vreeland, place within the enchantment of the narrative, real clothes to buy and wear. This is no time for fashion to offer excess, escapism and fantasy, reality is staring us in the face.
Note: I asked AI for help in not using Practical Magic and wonderfully it said, “for an outcome that feels like magic but is actually just highly organized or smart” Pragmatic sorcery, Applied wizardry, Functional alchemy, Common-sense sorcery, Grounded enchantment or Down-to-earth wizardry.





